Sims and the Lost Brilliance of Magazine Reviews

Searing reviews of their silly cash cow add-ons led EA to blacklist PC Zone.

The Sims 2: H&M Fashion Stuff

The Sims series of games come with an abundance of expansions to add more material to the games. But getting them reviewed in a games magazine wasn’t EA’s best idea…

Before the world wide web changed the way computer and video games were reported and written about, it was reviews in specialist magazines that had the ability – at least to some degree – to make or break the sales of a new release. There were other factors of course, but even 15 years ago, reviews in print magazines mattered, and major publishers invested a lot of time and energy in securing them.

Gradually, though, as with any industry, more and more titles became review-proof. We see this a lot in the movies, where a huge, blustering marketing campaign can paper over little trivialities such as whether a new film is actually any good. Look at the way most of the Transformers films were promoted – with barely a critic’s quote in sight on the poster – for ample evidence of that.

Let’s pretend

In the case of games, one of the breakout successes of the early 2000s was EA’s The Sims series, that’s still going strong to this day. We see the influence of The Sims in titles such as the staggeringly-successful Roblox to this day, but also EA continues to pump out releases. We’re up to The Sims 4 if you’re keeping score.

The Sims became such a huge part of EA’s business for a long time that it eventually set it up as a subdivision of its company. It wasn’t just the core releases either – The Sims 2 in 2004, The Sims 3 in 2009 – but the abundance of add-ons for the games. At least two of those a year were being shot out of its development cannon. 

At least two expansion packs a year were being shot out of EA’s development cannon…

If you’ve not tried The Sims, the best way of describing it is probably as a life simulation video game: a reality TV show in your computer or console You watch your characters, nudge them in certain directions, but ultimately you have no direct control over them. What you do have control of is the tat they interact, and this is where EA really hit gold: Sims add-on packs.

For The Sims 2 alone – which is where EA happened upon the idea – eight expansion packs and ten ‘stuff’ add-ons were released. The latter is where it was all at its most cynical, with punters being charged around a tenner a throw for – I’m not making this up – a pack full of virtual IKEA furniture. Another included wedding outfits and accessories. Nothing that materially affected the game, just some added cosmetic stuff. But they sold in huge quantities, and such expansion packs continue to this day. June 2021 saw the release of The Sims 4: Dream Home Decorator for instance, which sounds just amazing.

EA released IKEA Home Stuff alongside H&M Fashion Stuff

All of these intangible digital goods were on offer

Balance of power

But let’s go back to the 2000s, a cross-section where there was a still enough of a power spread between magazines and publishers that the latter sent everything to the former for review. How else could you get word out about your game?

One such magazine that took receipt of these add-on packs for review was the no longer with us PC Zone. 

Now PC Zone was a magazine not shy on character or opinion. After the release of one particularly bugged game, it ran a huge feature all about it illustrated by – there’s no easy way to say this – a picture of a massive shit across a double page spread. PC Zone was the magazine where Charlie Brooker started out. And PC Zone didn’t like The Sims add-on packs.

The reviews were assigned to a terrific writer by the name of Steve Hogarty, and it’d be fair to say that he didn’t hold back. Lots of people saw the cynicism in the add-on packs, and Hogarty put it into words.

The original Steve Hogarty evisceration of The Sims 2 in PC Zone

PC Zone scored its games out of 100, with 90 regarded as a ‘must buy’ and everything else scaled down from there. It awarded The Sims 2: H&M Fashion Stuff five out of 100, one of the lowest scores in the magazine’s history. Hogarty’s rightly-famed review of the pack can be read here, with a standfirst to set it up that simply reads “oh honestly, this can fuck right off”.

It was, for good measure, accompanied by a screenshot that declared in its caption ‘13% of the content is in this screenshot’. Ouch.

Trouble

But there was a story behind the scenes here. EA was incandescent at the reviews its add-ons were getting in the magazine. The reviews, again not unreasonably, savaged the add-on packs, and EA grew more and more irate as more were released, and more reviews were duly published. 

The H&M review was a tipping point, and Hogarty would reveal many years later in a now-deleted Tweet that “this is the review that got me blacklisted by EA”, adding “some shitbag executive wanted me fired”.

Hogarty wasn’t fired though. PC Zone, to its credit, very much stuck by him.

He would also explain of the score that “that’s a five out of one hundred, not ten. To score lower the game disc has to come whizzing out of the CD tray and lodge in your shin”.

Hogarty wasn’t fired though. PC Zone, to its credit, very much stuck by him. Furthermore, the problem of blacklisting a reviewer and not sending them games you wanted to sell was that, well, the games ended up in shops anyway. The magazine review team could just toddle along and buy a copy. Sure, the review might arrive a little later, but you could bet it was on its way.

Abyss

The cycle thus continued. Come the following year, when the aforementioned IKEA stuff pack was released for The Sims 2, Hogarty was specifically asked to “stick to the facts” when reviewing the add-on. His glorious review started ‘This is a content pack for the video game series The Sims 2. In it’ll you’ll find the following’, and then he preceded to simply list the items of virtual IKEA furniture contained within as the body of the article (slipping in, but you had to look for it, ‘deep abyss instead of a soul’ between a HEMNES bedside table and a BILLY bookcase). 

He signed off ‘I have considered the benefits and cost of this pack, and settled on a representative numerical value’. He gave it 25 out of 100. See below.

Winners and losers

The influence of games reviewers has now waned to the point where publishers oftentimes don’t even provide early copies for testing, meaning full, meaningful write-ups don’t land until a week or two after a title is available. Likewise, the era of computer and video games magazines is nearing its end. 

But in truth, the changing times were laid bare as those Sims add-ons kept coming. Games critics kept point out they weren’t very good, people kept buying them. EA was the one getting rich, as magazine circulations dropped with more people going online for their reading instead.

On the upside, though, Hogarty’s reviews have lived on, as has the legend of PC Zone, that finally closed its doors in September 2010 (the final issue was really quite something, with its story of the magazine told in a lot more detail than we’d had before). Quite what the magazine would have made of the aforementioned Dream Home Decorator pack is something we can only imagine…


Want to write for us? Email pitches to editorial@whynow.co.uk.


Leave a Reply

More like this