Keith Moon The Who Scot Halpin

When Keith Moon passed out on his drumkit and was replaced by a 19-year-old fan

In a twist that sounds like the plot of a coming-of-age rock ‘n’ roll movie, The Who’s concert at California’s Cow Palace in 1974 became the setting for an exceptional moment in music history. Keith Moon, the iconic drummer known as much for his offstage antics as his onstage prowess, succumbed to an ‘overindulgence’ that left the rest of the band in an almighty bind. 

It was then that 19-year-old Scot Halpin, a fan in the audience, found himself living every teenage rock ‘n’ roll fan’s dream: playing alongside the legends themselves.

Moon’s predilection for mixing horse tranquillisers with brandy before shows finally caught up with him, leaving him incapacitated mid-performance. The band, at the height of their powers with the number one album Quadrophenia fueling their tour, suddenly found themselves drummer-less.

In the middle of their hit ‘Won’t Get Fooled Again’, Moon’s drums went silent, signalling a premature end to his night and, unknowingly, setting the stage for Halpin’s incredible cameo.

Halpin, who had scored tickets on the day, could never have predicted his night turning out this way at the Cow Palace. With Moon whisked away for medical attention (he eventually had to have his stomach pumped), Pete Townshend’s desperate plea for a drummer found its answer in the young fan, bright-eyed and, most likely, bricking himself. Halpin’s swift ascent to the stage, backed by the endorsement of concert promoter Bill Graham, turned from surreal speculation to stark reality as he took his place behind Moon’s kit.


READ MORE: How did Keith Moon die? Inside the final days of The Who’s legendary drummer ‘Moon the Loon’


What followed was nothing short of miraculous. Breezing through the unfathomable task at hand, Halpin held his own through blues jams and a nine-minute rendition of ‘Naked Eye’. Despite lacking Moon’s explosive energy, Halpin ensured the show went on, a brilliant testament to both his skill and the inclusive spirit of rock ‘n’ roll that The Who embodied.

Scot-Halpin-Keith-Moon’s-Substitute
A slightly older Scot Halpin

The concert concluded with Halpin taking a bow alongside rock royalty as he was applauded by the audience and three of his heroes: Roger Daltrey, Pete Townshend, and John Entwistle. 

It was a fitting end to a night that epitomised the unpredictable magic of live music. His impromptu performance didn’t just fill a void; it etched his name into rock lore, offering a poignant reminder of music’s power to unite and transform.


READ MORE: Dear Young Me by Pete Townshend – The Who guitarist pens exclusive letter to his younger self


For Halpin, what began as a chance to witness his idol in action culminated in a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to be part of the very legend he admired. You can watch the entire spectacle in the video down below. 

The Who’s concert on that November night in 1974 remains a hallmark of rock history and perhaps the biggest warning sign of what was to come for Keith Moon himself, whose star shined so brightly it was eventually snuffed out by his own insatiable quest for living fast.


Keep up to date with the best in UK music by following us on Instagram: @whynowworld and on Twitter/X: @whynowworld


Leave a Reply

More like this

Best Albums 2023

Best albums of 2023, so far

From the triumphant return of Everything But The Girl to the extraordinary left-turn of Lil Yachty, the epic three-piece opera from Christine and the Queens to Foo Fighters’ beautiful study in grief, here are the best albums of 2023 – so far.